[ASM scene] Assembly graphics compo question

Martti Roitto martti.roitto at utu.fi
Fri Aug 8 11:17:22 EEST 2008


Jaakko Setälä wrote:
> Reading the license a couple of times revealed that the limitation you 
> mentioned does NOT apply on derivative work (just the photo as itself).

The widely accepted definition of derivative work includes translation, 
reproduction, abridgment, condensation, and adaptation in general, among 
other things that don't apply here.

I can't see how this work adapts anything or makes anything new out of 
the previously published photo. Colorization, adding a text and a few 
brush strokes is not even nearly enough original content to fit the 
definition.

Things would be greatly different had he, for example, recreated the 
photo in PS/whatever.

-- 
Martti "maraz" Roitto


More information about the Oldskool-list mailing list