[ASM scene] Assembly graphics compo question

[Jaakko Setälä]

Martti Roitto wrote:
> Jaakko Setälä wrote:
>> Reading the license a couple of times revealed that the limitation you 
>> mentioned does NOT apply on derivative work (just the photo as itself).
> 
> The widely accepted definition of derivative work includes translation, 
> reproduction, abridgment, condensation, and adaptation in general, among 
> other things that don't apply here.
> 
> I can't see how this work adapts anything or makes anything new out of 
> the previously published photo. Colorization, adding a text and a few 
> brush strokes is not even nearly enough original content to fit the 
> definition.

Could be, but I still dont think the license itself counts as a reason 
for disqualification. (Morally I do think that the entry is not fit as 
an 'original work of art' and should be disqualified)
I have to leave the final conclusions to compocrew and will be satisfied 
to any decision made by them.


-- 
Jaakko 'JJaska' Setälä
Assembly Organizing / Systems Crew Function Head